On This Day in History: The Final Day That Decided the Fate of a Nation

One hundred and sixty-one years ago today, the fate of the American nation hung in the balance on the rolling farmland of southern Pennsylvania. July 3, 1863, marked the climactic final day of the Battle of Gettysburg, a day that would see the largest artillery bombardment in the history of the Western Hemisphere, a desperate Confederate assault that came to be known as Pickett's Charge, and ultimately, the beginning of the end for the Confederate cause.

As dawn broke over Gettysburg on this fateful July morning, both armies knew that everything would be decided within the next few hours. After two days of brutal fighting that had left thousands dead and wounded scattered across the Pennsylvania countryside, Confederate General Robert E. Lee was determined to break the Union lines with one massive, coordinated assault. Union General George Meade, commanding the Army of the Potomac, was equally determined to hold his ground and repel Lee's invasion of the North.

The Calm Before the Storm

The early morning hours of July 3rd were deceptively quiet. Soldiers on both sides used the brief respite to tend to their wounded, write what they feared might be final letters home, and prepare for what everyone sensed would be a decisive confrontation. The Union forces, positioned along Cemetery Ridge in a formation that resembled a giant fishhook, held strong defensive positions. The Confederates, spread along Seminary Ridge about a mile away, were preparing for what Lee believed would be the war-winning assault.

Lee's plan was audacious in its simplicity and terrifying in its scope. He would concentrate his artillery—nearly 150 guns—and bombard the center of the Union line until it cracked. Then, approximately 15,000 Confederate infantry would charge across the open field between the ridges and smash through the weakened Union defenses, splitting the Army of the Potomac in two and opening the road to Washington, D.C.

The Great Bombardment

At 1:00 PM on July 3, 1863, the Confederate artillery opened fire in what became the largest artillery bombardment ever witnessed on the North American continent. For nearly two hours, Confederate cannons hurled death across the Pennsylvania farmland, with Union artillery answering in kind. The sound was so thunderous that it was heard as far away as Pittsburgh, over 150 miles distant.

Soldiers on both sides described the bombardment as hellish beyond imagination. The earth shook constantly, the air filled with acrid smoke, and the screaming of shells overhead was deafening. Union artilleryman Lieutenant Alonzo Cushing later wrote, "The very air seemed to be made of iron, and the ground appeared to dance beneath our feet."

Confederate artillery chief Colonel Edward Porter Alexander watched anxiously as his guns pounded the Union center. His mission was to silence the Union artillery and soften up the infantry for the coming assault. However, many of the Confederate shots were overshooting their targets, sailing harmlessly over Cemetery Ridge and into the Union rear areas.

Union artillery commander Brigadier General Henry Hunt made a calculated decision that would prove crucial to the day's outcome. After initially returning fire, he ordered his guns to cease firing, hoping to convince the Confederates that they had been silenced while actually conserving ammunition for the infantry assault he knew was coming.

Pickett's Charge: The High Water Mark of the Confederacy

Around 3:00 PM, as the artillery bombardment began to slacken, Confederate General James Longstreet reluctantly gave the order he had dreaded all day. Three divisions of Confederate infantry—commanded by Generals George Pickett, Johnston Pettigrew, and Isaac Trimble—began their mile-long advance across the open field toward Cemetery Ridge.

It was a magnificent and tragic sight that would be seared into the memory of every survivor. Nearly 15,000 Confederate soldiers emerged from the woods of Seminary Ridge in perfect battle formation, their battle flags flying, officers mounted on horseback, and the long gray lines stretching as far as the eye could see. Union soldiers watching from Cemetery Ridge could only marvel at the courage and discipline on display, even as they prepared to destroy it.

The advance began in textbook fashion, with the Confederate lines maintaining perfect order as they crossed the Emmitsburg Road and entered the deadly open ground. But as they drew closer to the Union lines, the carefully orchestrated assault began to unravel under the devastating firepower waiting for them.

The Union Response

As the Confederate assault reached the halfway point, Union artillery commander Henry Hunt's gamble paid off magnificently. His guns, which the Confederates believed had been silenced, suddenly roared back to life. Seventy Union cannons opened fire simultaneously, pouring canister shot—essentially giant shotgun blasts—into the advancing Confederate ranks.

The effect was devastating. Entire companies simply disappeared under the hail of metal. The perfectly aligned Confederate battle lines began to waver and break apart as men fell by the hundreds. Still, the survivors pressed forward with incredible determination, driven by their faith in Robert E. Lee and their belief that this assault would win the war.

Union infantry, protected behind stone walls and earthworks along Cemetery Ridge, held their fire until the Confederates were within 100 yards. Then, on command, thousands of Union rifles opened fire in coordinated volleys that cut down the advancing rebels like wheat before a scythe.

The Breakthrough That Failed

Against all odds, a small portion of the Confederate assault actually reached the Union lines. Brigadier General Lewis Armistead, leading his brigade with his hat on the tip of his sword, managed to cross the stone wall at what became known as "the Angle" and briefly planted the Confederate battle flag on Union soil. For a few desperate minutes, Confederate soldiers fought hand-to-hand with Union defenders in what historians would later call "the High Water Mark of the Confederacy"—the furthest point of Confederate advance in the war.

But the breakthrough was too little and too late. Armistead fell mortally wounded beside a Union cannon, and the few hundred Confederates who had reached the Union lines were quickly overwhelmed and captured or killed. The survivors of Pickett's Charge began the long, heartbreaking retreat back across the blood-soaked field, leaving behind nearly half of the men who had begun the assault just an hour earlier.

Lee's Moment of Truth

As the shattered remnants of his assault force straggled back to Seminary Ridge, Robert E. Lee rode out to meet them. Witnesses described the Confederate commander as visibly shaken, repeatedly saying, "It is all my fault. It is I who have lost this fight." For the first time in his military career, Lee had suffered a clear, undeniable defeat.

The failure of Pickett's Charge marked not just the end of the Battle of Gettysburg, but the beginning of the end for Confederate hopes of winning the war. Lee's army, which had seemed invincible just days before, was now broken and demoralized. The invasion of the North had failed catastrophically, and the Confederacy would never again possess the strength to mount a major offensive.

The Retreat Begins

As darkness fell on July 3, 1863, Lee began planning his retreat to Virginia. The next day, July 4th—Independence Day—the Army of Northern Virginia would begin its long, painful withdrawal from Pennsylvania, carrying with it over 5,000 wounded soldiers in a wagon train that stretched for miles.

The Battle of Gettysburg was over, and the Union had won the most important victory in American history. In three days of fighting, approximately 50,000 American soldiers had become casualties—killed, wounded, or missing. The Army of the Potomac had suffered around 23,000 casualties, while Lee's army had lost approximately 28,000 men, including many of his most experienced officers and non-commissioned officers.

The Turning Point

July 3, 1863, is remembered as the day the Confederacy reached its "High Water Mark"—the moment when Confederate independence seemed within grasp before slipping away forever. The failure of Pickett's Charge demonstrated that the Confederate army, no matter how brave or well-led, could not overcome the Union's advantages in manpower, artillery, and defensive position.

The psychological impact was equally devastating. Lee's aura of invincibility was shattered, while Union morale soared. The Army of the Potomac had finally proven it could defeat Lee in open battle, setting the stage for the final two years of the war.

A Day That Echoes Through History

One hundred and sixty-one years later, July 3, 1863, remains one of the most studied and commemorated days in American history. The courage displayed by soldiers on both sides—Union defenders holding their ground against overwhelming odds, and Confederate attackers advancing into certain death—exemplifies both the best and worst of human nature.

The failure of Pickett's Charge serves as a reminder that even the most carefully planned military operations can fail when faced with determined opposition and unfavorable circumstances. It also demonstrates how single days can alter the course of history, as the events of July 3, 1863, set in motion the chain of events that would lead to Union victory and the end of slavery.

Today, visitors to Gettysburg National Military Park can walk the same ground where Pickett's Charge unfolded, following the route taken by those brave Confederate soldiers across the field that locals still call "the Valley of Death." The stone wall where Armistead fell still stands, marked by monuments to both Union and Confederate courage.

As we remember July 3, 1863, we honor not just the Union victory that saved the nation, but all the Americans—North and South—who gave their lives on that Pennsylvania battlefield in service to their beliefs. Their sacrifice reminds us that the freedoms we enjoy today were purchased with blood, and that democracy, even in America, is never guaranteed but must be defended by each generation.

The echoes of that terrible and glorious day still resonate through American history, reminding us that sometimes the fate of nations truly does hang in the balance, decided by the courage of ordinary people facing extraordinary circumstances.

Read more about this history in these books: